Why Palins Down and Clintons Up

Time cools passions and adds perspective.This seems especially true for the tumultuous Republican love affair with Sarah Palin. It was intense, it was irrationaland its over.

Dick Cheney is just the latest conservative icon to join the chorus of voices who recognize that the selection of Sarah Palin for vice president was a major-league mistake. The man who first brought Palin to John McCain, Steve Schmidt, famously came to that conclusion before the 2008 campaign even ended.Now Team Romney doesnt even want her to be seen at the same podium in Tampa. And in perhaps the unkindest cut, Mindy Meyer, theLegally Blonde-inspired 22-year-old conservative New York State Senate candidate known in the tabloids as the Magenta Yenta, dismissed Palin by saying, She's just so oblivious to the issues.

READ MORE VP Picks Not Releasing Returns

Theres a reason for this broad-based cooling of affections.In the past four years, something like an organic consensus has emerged.Doubts that began with talk of death panels only grew with mutterings about blood libel. Over time, the reflexive Republican impulse to defend her honor became replaced with exhaustion and embarrassment.

Even some of the most devoted Palinites are left wondering what they were thinking.

READ MORE Mitts Missing Backbone

Take David Kelly of Colorado Springs, the one-time treasurer of the Draft Sarah 2012 committee. In 2009, when I interviewed him, Kelly believed that Palin represents the silent majority of this nation ... she invokes what conservative Americas all about: God and Country. Now hes come to a different conclusion.

You may be shocked to hear that I am no longer a Palin supporter, he told me over the phone. I think what attracted me to her in the first place was the fact that shed say things that youd hear at the Thanksgiving table when your relatives are there and go, Theres my crazy aunt, but she nails it every time.

READ MORE Why Democrats Backed Gay Marriage

But now?I realize that shes another Republican talking head, says Kelly, who is today a proud Ron Paul supporter. I dont thinkshe has the caliber to make a great leader for this nation in these times ... Shes off my radar. Its a sad statement.

Yes, its been a bad breakup. But signs of trouble were there for a long time.In December 2010, just one month after the Tea Party triumph, an ABC poll found that 59 percent of voters said they wouldnt cast a ballot for Palin and only 8 percent of Americans said theyd definitely vote for her.

READ MORE Elizabeth Warren Nabs DNC Speech

Almost a year later, in September 2011, a McClatchy-Marist poll found that by 72 percent to 24 perc! ent, Rep ublicans and Republican-leaning independents do not want Palin to run for president in 2012. Even among Tea Party supportersa group that likes Palin68 percent do not want her to run.

The polarization has faded in favor of a general understanding that for all her talents, Palin was not ready for presidential prime time.

READ MORE Dems to Add Gay Marriage

This new consensus is a vindication for her critics, especially Republican skeptics like Washington Post columnist Kathleen Parker, who described Palin as an attractive, earnest, confident candidate.Who Is Clearly Out Of Her League. In the hothouse atmosphere of 2008, Parkers statement earned her some 20,000 emails, many of this vintage: Youre not one of us, youre one of THEM, the liberal lovers, the flag-burners, country haters, the ones who want to kill god and put Stalin in his place and see this nation destroyed by a sea of brown people and gays.

Now even such inspired bile seems like a museum piece. Absent the chance that she could be a heartbeat away from the presidency (or a candidate herself), Palin no longer stirs the kind of passion that sold magazines and divided families.The fascination has faded.Instead, there is an aura of embarrassment bordering on amnesia, even from some one-time supporters. This dynamic will ultimately affect Michele Bachmann fans as well.

READ MORE Billboard Connects Obama to Aurora Shooting

While I was writing this column, an interesting bit of contrasting data hit the wires. Bill Clinton has a 66 percent approval rating, matching his all-time high.Coincident with this news is the announcement that Bubba will be the Wednesday night keynote speaker of the Democratic convention in North Carolina.

It is surreal but true to say that Bill Clinton is now the Republicans favorite living Democratic president, a person who even Newt Gingrich now refers to with nostalgia and something like respect.

READ MORE Romneys Israeli Faux Pas

No more is Clinton attacked as far-left 60s radicalhe is recognized as the essentially centrist Southern governor he always said he was.His wifeperhaps even more hated by the right in the 1990sis widely regarded as a stabilizing force in the Obama administration as secretary of state.

One interpretation of this reversal of fortune is that the Clintons look good because the Obamas are so bad.But reflect on the fact that so many of the attacks are the sameincluding a column originally published on WorldNetDaily calling Clinton a Marxist Manchurian candidateand you quickly come to the more obvious conclusion that the problem lies in the reflexive hyper-partisanship that distorts the characters of political figures beyond realistic recognition.

READ MORE Palestinians: Romney Speech Racist

Over time, we start to see t! hese fig ures more clearly.No one is as good as intense advocates believe or as bad as overheated opponents insist.But I think it is worthwhile to note that the more reasoned criticism of Sarah Palin now seems to be widely accepted.And on the flip side, American consensus about Bill Clintonfor all his well-documented flawshas erred on the side of his moderate defenders.Objectivity is elusive, but eventually something like balance creeps into our assessments.The result is not always nonpartisan.

The takeaway for this current election is to not fall for the overheated attacksor overzealous defensesof either candidate, especially when they echo old fear-mongering scripts. Falling for the fever of hyper-partisanship tends to make fools of us all, in time.

Related from The Daily Beast

• Tomasky: "We'd Like To See Our Politicians Have Some Kind of Backbone"
• Bob Schieffer: "I Think It Could Hurt Him"
• Romney: Spiritual Connection to Israel

Like us on Facebook - Follow us on Twitter - Sign up for The Cheat Sheet Newsletter